LED HEADLIGHT OPTION FOR THE MODEL S

t7n7

Hey guys,

I currently drive an X650 and it was no brainer for me to consider an all electric vehicle for work and keep the X for the weekends.. (The BMW averages about 19L/100km .. I drive it hard the way it's meant to be driven)

So I reserved my MODEL S last week... #141 Canada... just for those of you that are doing the reservation updates... (Feb 25th 2011)

http://image.automobilemag.com/f/31533285+w750+st0/2011-audi-a8-led-headlights.jpg

The image above (sorry, tried attaching, didn't work) is the LED HEADLIGHTS for the 2011 Audi A8. My question is, wouldn't it be more efficient to use LEDs then regular HID lights? ... especially when we need to milk every bit of power...

Considering the headlights is one of the most important and mostly used devices in a car. Not sure about the specs of the A8 headlights but looks like AUDI is rolling towards LED headlights for all their future cars.. A7, A6 (2012) etc which leads me to believe that, they are better and more efficient

Please let me know what you guys think and if LED Headlights might be an option a year away.


p.s: please don't get confused with AUDI's daytime running LED lights... these are full LED Headlights

Timo

Do you have any info about how much light those produce? Comparison to other headlights?

I pretty much don't care about wattage use, but LEDs make perfect sense for durability if you can produce enough light with them. LED lights last a lot longer than any other lightsource.

Unknown

They now make LED lights as replacements for landing lights on Aircraft. This is a place where only the brightst lights would do in the past.

http://www.aircraftspruce.com/menus/el/ledlighting_landing.html

William13

The problem seems to be that the special customized shapes needed are currently very expensive.

Sudre

I would prefer just the normal bulb and then I will go to...
http://www.superbrightleds.com

if I want to upgrade to an LED.

That sight seems to stay at the cutting edge of LED tech at very reasonable prices.

Sudre

I should have mentioned that night time replacement head lights are not there yet.

Brian H

From the aviation site:
"1600 LANDING LIGHTS
(FOR OPEN AIRFLOW)

The 1600 is a wing-mounted LED (Light Emitting Diode) landing light with a built-in wig wag mode in addition to its standard operation as a landing/taxi light. The AeroSUN is a very intense light source that uses 8 high power LEDs to produce up to 1600 lumens of light using just 24 Watts of power."

Thets a hull lotta lumens!

Timo

Based on chart I found here: http://www.danielsternlighting.com/tech/bulbs/bulb_types/bulb_types.html

that 1600 is pretty normal high beam car light value. That 24W is only about half H4 wattage, so saved wattage is not as big as I expected. You probably do save in durability though.

jkirkebo

1600 lumens is not much. My Oracle 35W HID flashlight puts out 3200 lumens, my 30W HID bike light around 1800 lumens.

HIDs seems to still be the way to go.

Peak Oil bruin

Would appreciate LEDs, my residential watts coming from PV panels. That being said, I don't care for the cutesy Audi LED arrays

t7n7

first of all.. it's 1600lumens PER headlight TIMO. So what do you exactly mean, saved wattage is what you didn't expect? WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? Do your research... seriously... HIDs are normally 3200Lumens both channels. and if Audi engineered it.. it obviously has big savings... not to mention, it has better durability and a longer lifespan...

and since your using headlights almost everyday and for a good period of time, any bit of savings is a big thing.

Also... check this out if you have time: www.youtube.com/wisht7n7

That's my youtube channel, i work on cars and that's my project I worked on a few years back.... so I know what i'm talking about.

dashrb

@t7n7, nice work.

Timo

What did I expect? A bit better W/lumen performance. Wasn't that obvious? Strange. I don't find any bad grammar errors or unclear sentences in my writing. Odd that you didn't understand it, t7n7.

msiano17

guys relax, there is no reason to start attacking each other on the boards. we are here to discuss and debate not to attack each other's opinions or ideas.

plus t7n7 if you do know a lot about a subject then you educate us not condemn what we say.. correct and support with facts not bashing someone else

searcher

Are you kidding msiano17, this is war,ha. It's ok though it just makes you tougher, smarter, better informed, more respectful, just look at some of my older post compared to now. You learn tactiturn above all.<p> Just kidding msiano17 of course you are right.<p>Often wonder what it's like in R&D though.

VolkerP

Back to topic here. Thanks t7n7 for the initial post. I opened my eyes and noted an Audi with LED headlights only for the first time this week.
LED only headlight is surely a "wow" issue. Due to higher cost will be included in the premium models first. Energy savings are not pivotal at the moment.

I think car designers are in a torment here. They need to keep the bulky headlights as the "eyes" in a car's "face". At least for the premium and middle class cars. But LED elements can be built quite more compact. Audi arranged the LEDs in a conventional looking headlight. I assume they deliberately didn't explore the new design possibilities. All Audi models must share a "brand face" regardless of technology, not only the top models A8, A7, A6.

So I expect we'll see <b>compact<b> LED only headlight in small car classes (where customers go for price, not for great looks) and in some design studies (where it is OK to look - alien). Gradually, customers will be accompanied to the new look and car manufacturers will use it more courageously in the higher class cars.

I think Tesla is not daring to "look different" with Model S when it comes out. Would be quite a stab to have every Joe's wife comment on your new Model S "How awful, it has no headlights!" Conclusion, LED headlights might be an option but will be integrated in a "conventional" looking headlight.

Volker.Berlin

@VolkerP, I agree with most of what you said, but

<i>Would be quite a stab to have every Joe's wife comment on your new Model S "How awful, it has no headlights!" </i>

I do not think that this would be an issue in the real world. Cars that hide their headlights during the day have been around for quite a while, and generally have been perceived as very slick if not beautiful, e.g., the old Mazda MX5, Mazda 323F, Volvo 480, Opel GT. The only problem was that the mechanism to fold away the headlights is hard (i.e., expensive) to design such that it reliably works through a car's entire lifetime. My gut feeling would agree with your suspicion, but these examples have already proven that "no big headlights" is no big problem from a design perspective.

Brian H

Reponse to Joe's wife: "How awful! No brain lights!"

Timo

One reason why car lights have common look is both practicality and safety. Two lights at certain semi-standard height and width can help determining distances in dark roads. It is a lot harder to tell how far away a motorcycle is than a passenger car. I think there are laws of how close together lights can be, so every possible arrangement just isn't possible.

t7n7

@dashrb , thanks!

my apologies for coming across rude... didn't mean to. As for the headlights... VolkerP got it right on.... eventually it will trickle down to normal cars.

if they can save space from traditional headlights.... they would be able to make a more aerodynamic body... etc. I can see Audi taking advantage of this in the future... only makes sense!

Kallisman

I read somewhere, in a magazine I think, that the big suppliers of car lighting have already stopped R&D on HID and focus on LED now. So we will probably see more and better LED lights soon.

jkirkebo

There's not much more R&D to be done on HIDs anymore, it's a mature technology. My e-bike have 3 HID lights...

rj

My friend has an Audi Q5 with LED daylight running lights. He's had the LEDs fail 2x. On installation of third set, the dealer told him Audi having many problems with them. (I have no idea what the problems are.)

VolkerP

was it a partial or complete blackout? Audi Q5 daylight running lights are 5 to 6 LED units. If they fail all together, I assume the power supply unit failed. I understand that several single LEDs may fail in a unit of 6 before the car maker would accept it as his fault and exchange the unit.

Roblab

Ah, my favorite subject!
Many years ago all headlights were round and about 8" across. Then someone designed rectangular headlights, and everyone said, "How neat. Now they can make the car more aerodynamic". The next year they were putting rectangular lights on the new cars, in vertical pairs.
And then we have Pickup Trucks. These bad boys are allowed to be jacked up, loaded up, and driven with the main beam right into the eyes of oncoming traffic. The lights sit at about 6 feet, and the headlights are never re-aligned for safe driving. And don't forget to turn on the no-pattern fog lights down under the bumper which are aimed up into the oncoming traffic.
Then there are the guys who are afraid of the dark and drive with the high beams on at all times. Or are simply unaware that they even have any control over the lights.
And then, we have the issue of Daytime Running Lights, which are high beams with a little less power to the filament, but they still shine in your eyes.
I think the issue is NOT what kind of a light generator you have, but where you put the light. Most people don't know, don't care, and wouldn't know how to adjust headlights or replace a bulb. LEDs don't fix the basic problem.

Brian H

anern is a spammer. IMO.